A primary school in the Highlands of Scotland has stopped setting homework for its 175 children. Apparently 80% of the pupils and 60% of the parents were in agreement. This school is the latest in a long string of schools around the world scrapping homework.
I have to wonder at this decision. Is it because the parents and teachers have no control over the children, who do not wish to complete any set homework and therefore have been allowed to cop out, or is it because the council think the children learn enough during school hours and need to play when they return home? The article goes on to say that in Spain, pupils from 12,000 schools have refused to do any homework at weekends for a whole month.
When I was at school I do not remember having any homework in my primary school, but once I moved to grammar school and then on to secondary school after a house move it was customary to receive homework every night. I diligently completed this and didn’t even think about rebelling and refusing to hand any in. In my grammar school a child was kept in after lessons had ended to finish the task if they had not completed the previous night’s homework.
Fast forward 25 or so years and it’s the turn of my sons to bring homework back after school. My youngest son would always complete whichever task he was set, but dear Leon, my eldest son, was and is one of life’s rebels. It was my distasteful job to ensure that when he was in middle school he completed whatever work had been set. This involved much shouting on my part (in the days when I could shout) and much deferring of the task on his. Eventually I realised the teachers were not even bothering to mark it quite a lot of the time, and I felt angry at all the effort I had gone through to ensure he gave it in when he was supposed to. Right then and there I stopped bothering to remind him, much to my son’s amazement.
When Leon started at senior school I informed him that it was now up to him whether he did homework or not, as he needed to experience the consequences of his actions. I stated that if he did not complete the homework set, then he might start to fall behind, which might then mean that he eventually received a low score in his GCSE exams. Leon did not really care whether or not he incurred the wrath of his teachers or received bad exam results. Unfortunately he did receive bad exam results in a few of the subjects, but he hid his disappointment well. It was only once he started day release college at the age of 16 as an apprentice engineer, paid for by his employer, that he found subjects he was interested in. He was working with people older than him, and he completed his course work and homework without so much as a murmur. He is now 34 and on the first rung of the management level of a national company, barking out orders to his underlings and loving every minute of it. We found out much to our surprise that our rebel son is a born leader!
Does it matter whether primary school children get any homework? I would say it doesn’t really matter at all. They are tired of studying when they come home, and all they want to do is play. As they grow older and big exams loom, then they must be aware of the consequences of not doing the required course work or homework, but they must learn to be self-motivated and suffer the consequences of their actions. I for one remember the stress of trying to get somebody to do homework in a subject they were not interested in. Girls I think are more diligent and like to please, but boys, especially our boy, could not really give a toss.
What do you think? Do primary school children need to do homework?
Bernadette said:
Stevie, I have always been somewhat anti homework. I know that learning needs reinforcement but also children (and adults) just need time to be in order to open up their creativity.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Stevie Turner said:
Yes I agree, especially young children – they need to play.
LikeLike
lisaorchard1 said:
There have been studies done in Finland, I believe, where they found that doing homework did not improve test results in Elementary aged kids. In fact, they found that more recess is very beneficial. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
robjodiefilogomo said:
Maybe they don’t need homework at that age, but I do think they need some reading before bed or some kind of reinforcement that what they are learning is needed out in the world. My mom used to have me read the menu to her, or try to figure out the tip when I was young!!
jodie
http://www.jtouchofstyle.com
LikeLiked by 2 people
Stevie Turner said:
Yes, I taught both my boys to read before they went to school. To not be able to read leaves a person at a terrible disadvantage throughout life.
LikeLiked by 2 people
watchingthedaisies said:
We had reading and spelling homework in primary school. It was nice to share these with my mum when my sisters and I got home and she always encouraged us in our efforts.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Clive said:
The only homework I had at primary school was reading, and I’m not sure that was official anyway. That was 1958-1964, and was still the same when my daughters were at primary school, between 1991 and 2003. I think reading should be encouraged in this way, as it underpins everything we do and we’ll end up with a nation of Jeremy Kyle Show-style retards if we aren’t careful. Maybe a little maths too, for the same reason. But it’s too early for much more than that.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Stevie Turner said:
Yes, my granddaughter brings her reading book home from school most afternoons, but the eldest one aged 11 is now being given homework every day, much to her disgust.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Clive said:
I guess they’re preparing her for ‘big school.’ Probably for the best, but she’ll never believe that!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Stevie Turner said:
She is at ‘big school’ now, as they’ve done away with the middle schools in our area.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Clive said:
Ah, I see. Middle schools weren’t invented in my time, or in place for my girls. Essex hasn’t adopted them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
franklparker said:
Primary school was such a long time ago! I remember my mother thought it was important that I should pass the 11+ I can’t recall if the homework I did towards that goal was set by the school or just by her (perhaps advised by one of the teachers at the school). It included her dictating written passages for me to write out in order to improve my spelling. I still struggle with spelling!
I doubt it is really necessary for primary school children to do homework, certainly not in the early years. If it is set, then it ought to be relevant and interesting. I’m thinking of practical tasks, perhaps related to the environment or understanding how maths and science have everyday applications at home. The kind of stuff that used to feature on Blue Peter, for example.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Stevie Turner said:
Good thinking there Frank!
LikeLiked by 1 person
malcolmarchibald said:
No: or only a very little. Small children need freedom and family time far more than they need to know details of algebra or punctuation.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Stevie Turner said:
Yes I agree, but it needs to be gradually brought in as they reach teenage years.
LikeLike